Smug Villager Tier List

[Pandemonium]

Probably my second least favorite personality type.

 

[Watchingthetreetops]

"I don't want to get involved"

that killed me xD

 

[Wolfieocelot]

I know, raymond is my s tier....

 

[Seelie]

I definitely thought I liked this personality type more than this tier list suggests :')

I had both Raymond and Kyle on my previous island and probably would've put them both as S or A tier back when New Horizons released, but I never really clicked with either of them. Shep, on the other hand, is absolutely my boy, and the A-tier villagers have all just kind of grown on me unexpectedly.

 

[paleogamer11]

I know this is opinion based, but why is almost everyone putting Lucha in D tier? I think he’s fantastic!

 

[SoftenedHearts]

I love that little clown... (also F tier is reserved for villagers that make me Uncomfortable as opposed to regular dislike, and I actually really like Hippeaux's design as a snooty anime joke antagonist)

 

[MadisonBristol]

 

[Kars]

Zell is finally getting some much deserved love haha! I always thought he was underrated.

 

[Dunquixote]

Still only two villagers in S tier for me, but I got a lot of villagers in A tier. Even Rodney. Been interested in him increasingly thanks to @Chungus & @Le Ham both of whom have posted some incredible adorable pictures of him. I’ve been interested in Lopez for awhile. Huck, Henry, Colton are the ones that I have developed interest in fairly recently.

I am surprised that I actually have a few villagers from a species that I don’t like the general designs of such as Ken; I really like his color scheme and Hans seems pretty interesting.

 

[Xara]

i would like to sincerely apologize to pietro for dropping him in the D tier last time,, i am truly a bigger clown than He,,

Spoiler: may 2020 list

 

[heaven.]

I think smug might be my least favourite personality, I just don't vibe with their dialogue most of the time lol.

 

[ripley4O77]

Smugs are just filled with ugly. Great overall personality though! I never saw Ken before ACNH and he quickly became a dreamie of mine! When I started hunting for him I found him after THIRTY NTMT only!!

 

[visibleghost]

Shep, Henry and Marshal are great villagers. I would love to have Henry again.
I had Kidd and Zell on my New Horizons island and I liked them but got tired of them after a while.
I don't love the horses but Colton and Julian are cute! I had Colton by mistake (accidentally picked up through the void) but I really liked him and his regal style. Raymond is okay I guess but I wouldn't say he is close to being my favourite smug villager.

There are a lot of ugly smugs too. I feel a little bit bad putting Phil together with Huck (Only disgusting frog) and Hamphrey and that sickly looking hamster, whatever his name is, but yeah. Quillson reminds me of a sick private school boy who has too much confidence and tells people his father will hear about this.

 

[paleogamer11]

Now that Toby has been in the game since earlier this year, I would like to see updated versions, please. For me personally, I would rank him in either B or C, since I haven’t had enough time to form a good opinion on him and he appears a teensy bit disturbing to me.

 

[Croconaw]

Shep and Kyle are in their own their. I personally love Marshal because of his New Leaf house interior. The sloppy set is my favorite set from that game. I used the full set for my living room. Raymond looks cool, but I honestly don’t understand the hype around him. I won’t knock him for his popularity, but I do like him as a villager. Ken is my most liked in the A tier. He’s basically a ninja chicken.

 

[WaileaNoRei]

Now that Toby has been in the game since earlier this year, I would like to see updated versions, please. For me personally, I would rank him in either B or C, since I haven’t had enough time to form a good opinion on him and he appears a teensy bit disturbing to me.

I recently created a new thread with a link to a tier maker that includes Toby here:

What’s your personal tier list? - smug villagers

I love seeing how different everyone’s tastes are in villagers. Even though sometimes it seems like everyone likes the same group of popular villagers, I find really most people like a mix of popular and unpopular villagers. I’ve also found that my opinions on villagers are constantly changing...

www.belltreeforums.com

 

[Snek]

Lets see...a year later...how have things changed with the smugs? I liked Raymond more. Not much else.

 

[Stalfie]

 

[smug villager]

Smug villagers have all my favorite designs. I have too many of them! I wish there wad more dialogue variety, it gets repetitive.

 

[Mestear]